Since the Oscars are going to start up in a few hours I’d like to give a quick review of the animated shorts that are nominated for an Academy Award this year. Let’s jump right in!

ADAM AND DOG  (Minkyu Lee)

Consensus:  Featuring beautiful hand-drawn animation by the likes of James Baxter, Jennifer Hager, Mario Furmanczyk, Austin Madison, and Matt Williames, Minkyu Lee’s very personal and profound short film was the highlight of the short selection for me.

I loved the rough-around-the-edges look of the film, and it takes no shame in being drawn. Many hand-drawn films and shows today are so polished looking that they sometimes look a bit too smooth or”vector-y”. There’s a much warmer hand-made feel to the animation here that makes it feel a lot more personal. The story is excellent too. I loved the animation on the dog. Having a dog of my own, I can say 100% that the animators got it spot on.


PAPERMAN (John Khars)

Consensus: This nice little film directed by Pixar veteran animator John Kars, is an interesting hybrid of hand-drawn and CG techniques. It has all the warmth of the hand-drawn “look” (thanks to the likes of animators like Eric Goldberg and Alex Kuperschmidt who contributed to the final line drawings) with all the incredibly subtle animation in the face and eyes that CG can bring to the table.

It’s the best of both worlds and it’s certainly worth seeing just for the incredible visuals alone (though the story held up nicely too!)

Paperman Model Sheets



Consensus: This was definitely the most commercial of nominated shorts. However, that doesn’t mean it’s not charming and funny in its own right. I liked that, for a change, a Simpsons cartoon was made 100% without dialogue and that the animation was allowed to drive the story.

While it’s not as personal as ADAM AND DOG, PAPERMAN, FRESH GUACAMOLE, or HEAD OVER HEELS, it’s certainly a fun little film with a lot of great visual gags. My only regret is that I didn’t get to see it in 3D!



Consensus: Pes’s FRESH GUACAMOLE made me very hungry for sure. He really has a way of making inanimate objects look edible!


HEAD OVER HEELS (Timothy Reckart and Fodhla Cronin O’Reilly)

Consensus: HEAD OVER HEELS was a sweet little stop-motion film by Timothy Reckart and Fodhla Cronin O’Reilly. It really has a great hand-crafted look and great emotional kick to it!


Enjoy the Oscars, everybody!



Previous post

Tom Bancroft Interview - Character Mentor Workshops

Next post

Elite Animation Academy - Adult Classes

The Author

James Nethery

James Nethery

James knew that he wanted to do animation from a very early age thanks to his father being an animator at the Walt Disney Studio. When he was in his teens, he took a serious interest in the art of animation and then, finally, in the year 2011 James graduated from Animation Mentor: The Online Animation School with a diploma in Advanced Character Animation Studies. James is currently working for Floyd County Productions on Archer.

No Comment

Leave a reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.